Coalition for Education Funding Reform

CEFR - NY

 

Property Taxes in NY State

 (Excerpt from NY Comptroller Report April 2006)

Property Tax is the largest tax imposed by local governments in the state, representing 79% of all taxes outside of New York City. Per capita property tax burdens in New York State are 49% higher than the national average, 73% higher outside of New York City, and 28% higher than the national average when measured as a share of personal income.  Property taxes add to the overall high cost of living in downstate suburbs, where property taxes per $1,000 of personal income average about $65 compared to the State median of $53. Local property tax levies increased 42% from 2000 to 2005, three times the rate of inflation.

www.osc.state.ny.us/localgov/pubs/research/propertytaxes.pdf

 Westchester County is the highest taxed county in the nation paying a median property tax of $7,337.

http://money.cnn.com/2006/10/03/pf/property_taxes/index.htm?postserver

 

Last Spring the Coalition for Education Funding Reform was created by a group of concerned residents from the Tuckahoe School District.  The objective of the group is to change the way that education is funded in New York State; specifically to reduce the tax burden upon property owners, to find alternate sources of revenue, and to develop an equitable funding formula. 

 

In the Tuckahoe School District, property owners are funding 90% of the School District budget through property taxes.  New York State aid covers less than 10% of the budget for the school year.  Governor Spitzer’s proposed 2007-2008 budget will cut $30,533 or 1.7% from our existing total state aid package and increase taxes.

 

Property taxes are considered a stable source of revenue but they are a regressive tax, meaning that the burden tends to fall more heavily on lower-income taxpayers and does not take into account one's ability to pay.  Instead of a uniform statewide, professional and equitable assessment, property taxes are based on a locally determined property valuation process resulting in uneven assessments.  While the STAR program provides some relief to property owners, it is a transfer of a tax burden, not a tax cut and is not a permanent solution.

 

Progressive taxes such as income and sales taxes should be considered as alternate sources of income, as well as assigning all the proceeds of the lottery to education as originally intended.  In addition, the State and Federal government need to fully fund the mandates they force upon school districts and provide reform of onerous legislation such as repealing the Wick's Law which adds 10-15% to construction costs for school district projects.

 

The Campaign for Fiscal Equity (CFE) v. State of New York decision found that the current school funding system violates the state constitutions guarantee of a "sound basic education" to New York City students.* An estimated $8.5 billion dollars of additional aid will be needed to fund this decision, and the Tuckahoe School district will receive $0.00 additional dollars of state aid.

 

We are asking every resident of the Tuckahoe School district to write a letter to the Governor, and our legislative representatives to ask them to make equitable funding reform of education a priority for their upcoming legislative agenda.  We have attached a letter below that can be copied and pasted for your personal editing, and a .PDF copy that you can download, sign and send.  We have also included the names and contact information for our representatives and other legislators that need to know our concerns.

 

If we want to preserve our school district, our property values, our way of life, we will all need to make changing the way education is funded in the State of New York a priority for ourselves and our representatives.

 

PLEASE NOTE THESE IMPORTANT DATES:

 

March 31, 2007 - deadline for the State Legislature to adopt a budget

 

  April 10, 2007 - projected deadline for Governor to sign budget into law.

 

Tips for writing an effective letter

An effective letter to a legislator needs three things:

1.  Put your name and address at the end of your letter AND on the envelope. 

Legislative Members need to know that you are one of the people they represent.

2Ask for specific action. 

For example: “I ask that you find alternate sources of revenue to reduce the reliance upon property taxes for funding education in the state of New York.”

3.  Give a reason.  Say something about your motivation and/or state a fact.

 For example: “Westchester County is the highest taxed County in the nation.  I  will not be able to continue living in my home unless action is taken now to reduce the tax burden on property owners.

**A personal comment will help to attract their attention and will allow you to tell them how high property taxes are affecting you and your family.

 

 

SAMPLE LETTER

 

  • The following letter is available for your use. Feel free to copy and paste into a Word document for your personal editing. A personal comment will help to attract their attention and will allow you to tell them how high property taxes are affecting your family.
  • A downloadable .PDF version is also available below our sample.
  • Remember to include your contact information before you sign and send to the contacts listed below.                                   

 

 

Honorable                   ,

 

As a resident of the Tuckahoe School District in Westchester County, I am writing to ask that you support all efforts to reform public education funding and to reduce the reliance upon property taxes as the main funding source for public education in New York State. 

Westchester County is the highest taxed county in the nation.  The current NYS funding formula provides less than 10% of the Tuckahoe School District budget; as a result Tuckahoe property owners now fund more than 90% of the Tuckahoe School District budget.   

This dependence upon property taxes unfairly places the burden of education funding on one segment of the community, the property owner, and therefore can be viewed as regressive and discriminatory. Continually rising property taxes will cause current residents to leave, prevent new families from moving in and will result in depreciating real estate values. 

We ask that you develop new, more equitable methods of funding that utilize other sources of revenue such as income or sales taxes- progressive taxes that reflect an individual’s ability to pay, and insure that all lottery proceeds be allocated to education as was originally intended.  Regional costs of living must be considered to be equitable.

We are not seeking reform at the expense of our children, but are advocating foremost for a sound education for all the children in the state through an improved education funding process that redistributes the burden of funding education to all the residents of New York State, not just property owners.

Please make a commitment to my neighbors and me to put education funding reform at the top of your legislative agenda.  I look forward to hearing of your efforts on our behalf.

 

Sincerely,

 

 

 

Tuckahoe School District Property Owner

 

Download letter by clicking here:  CEFR LETTER.PDF

 

Federal

New York State Representatives

 

Senator Charles E. Schumer (D)*

Governor Eliot Spitzer (D)*

 

313 Hart Senate Building

Executive Chambers

 

Washington, DC 20510

State Capitol

 

 

T: (202)224-6542

Albany, New York 12224

 

F: (202)228-3027

T: (518)474-8390

 

 

http://www.schumer.senate.gov

F:  (518)474-1513

 

 

 

http://www.ny.gov/governor/contact

 

 

 

 

 

 

Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton (D) *

Senator Jeffrey D. Klein (D-NY 34th)

United States Senate

Legislative Office Building, Room 415

476 Russell Senate Office Building

Albany, New York 12247

 

Washington, DC 20510

T: (718)822-2049

 

 

T: (202)224-4451

F: (718)822-2321

 

 

F: (202)228-0282

http://www.nyssenate34.com

 

http://www.clinton.senate.gov

E-mail:  jdklein@senate.state.ny.us

 

 

 

 

 

Representative Nita M. Lowey (D)*

Assemblywoman Amy R. Paulin (D-NY 88th)

2329 Rayburn House Office Building

District Office

 

 

Washington, DC 20515

700 White Plains Road, Suite 252

T: (202)225-6506

Scarsdale, New York 10583

 

F: (202)225-0546

T: (914)723-1115

 

 

http://www.house.gov/lowey

F:  (914)723-2665

 

 

 

http://www.assembly.state.ny.us

 

 

E-mail:  paulina@assembly.state.ny.us

 

 

 

 

 

Westchester County

 

 

 

 

County Executive Andrew Spano

County Legislator Vito Pino (Distict 10)

148 Martine Avenue

148 Martine Avenue

 

 

White Plains, NY 10601

White Plains, NY 10601

 

T: (914) 995-2900

T: (914) 995-2800

 

 

E-mail:  ceo@westchestergov.com

F: (914) 994-3884

 

 

http://www.westchestergov.com/cexec

http://www.westchesterlegislators.com

 

 

 

 

Additional Representatives to Contact

New York State Assembly Speaker

New York State Senate Majority Leader

Assemblyman Sheldon Silver

Senator Joseph L. Bruno (R)

Legislative Office Building 932

Legislative Office Building, Room 909

Albany, New York 12248

Albany, New York 12247

T: (518)455-3791

T: (518)455-3191

F: (518)455-5459

F: (518)455-2448

www.assembly.state.ny.us

www.senatorbruno.com

E-mail:  speaker@assembly.state.ny.us

E-mail:  bruno@senate.state.ny.us

 



New York State Assembly Real Property Taxation , Chair

Assemblywoman Sandy Galef

 

Legislative Office Building 641

 

Albany, New York 12248

 

T: (518)455-5348

 

F: (518)455-5728

 

www.assembly.state.ny.us

 

E-mail:  galefs@assembly.state.ny.us

                               

How else can you help? 

  • Share this letter with ten people, especially neighbors without children in the district who may not be aware of the Coalition’s efforts to reform the education funding formula to reduce the tax burden upon property owners. 
  • Get Active. Write a letter to the editor, talk to friends and neighbors about property tax reform, and pay attention to what your representatives are doing, or not doing, to make this issue a priority on their legislative agenda.  
  • Get informed.  We have attached a number of links below that we have found to be sources of information or reflect current movements and opinions throughout the state. There are groups that have organized all over New York State to reduce property taxes and redistribute the cost of education equitably.  Westchester County is considered by many outside of the county to be "Wealthy" and not in need of property tax reform so we need to make sure that they realize that high taxes are hurting all New Yorkers.  The high cost of living in this area also needs to be considered in any equitable property tax, income tax, and school funding reform.
  • Join our efforts by contacting The Coalition for Education Funding Reform today!                     Email: CEFRNY@gmail.com

Informative Links:

 

April 2006 Alan Hevesi Comptroller Report:

www.osc.state.ny.us/localgov/pubs/research/propertytaxes.pdf

Alliance for Quality Education:   www.aqeny.org  Campaign for Fiscal Equity  

This report shows the aid that every school district in the state will receive as a result of the CFE decision. *Note page 17, Tuckahoe and most of Westchester County will receive $0.00 in aid. http://www.aqeny.org/cms_files/File/SNYFA%20Distric%20Runs%202006.pdf

*The New York State Court of Appeals ruling on the Campaign for Fiscal Equity (CFE) v. State of New York decision found that the current school funding system violates the state constitutions guarantee of a "sound basic education" to New York City students. There has been general agreement that a statewide policy response to the CFE decision will be necessary and it has been estimated that an additionally $8.5 billion annually will be needed to adequately fund education.  The Tuckahoe School District is located within Westchester County, considered to be a wealthy county and is not slated for any additional state funding under this ruling.  Neither are most of the other school districts in the county.

 

Property Tax Reform Task Force:  www.hvpropertytaxreform.org

Citizens Action of New York:   www.citizenactionny.org

 

DID YOU KNOW?  That Westchester County, the highest taxed county in the nation, is not eligible for High Tax Aid under the current School Funding Formula (page 7)?  This is a $30 per pupil supplement.  We are too poor for high tax aid, and too rich for any state aid . . .